Matthew Hayden Vs Herschelle Gibbs, Who is better and Why??

Comparison Between Matthew Hayden And Herschelle Gibbs:

Matthew Hayden Vs Herschelle Gibbs

First look at stats:

Matthew Hayden stats

Batsman

Career Batting Stats

Left-Handed Batsman

Format	M	Inn	NO	Runs	HS	Avg	BF	BF	SR	100s	50s
Test 1994–09	103	184	14	8625	380	50.7	14349	437	60.1	30	29
ODI 1993–08	161	155	15	6133	181*	43.8	7767	166	79.0	10	36
T20I 2005–07	9	9	3	308	73*	51.3	214	48	143.9	0	4

Herschelle Gibbs stats

Batsman

Career Batting Stats

Right-Handed Batsman

Format	M	Inn	NO	Runs	HS	Avg	BF	BF	SR	100s	50s
Test 1996–08	90	154	7	6167	228	42.0	12270	240	50.3	14	26
ODI 1996–10	248	240	16	8094	175	36.1	9721	111	83.3	21	37
T20I 2005–10	23	23	1	400	90*	18.2	318	55	125.8	0	3

For Tests:

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Batting Average)

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Batting Strike Rate)

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Runs in Innings)

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Runs in Career)

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Total Hundreds)

Its 5:0 means Matthew Hayden is best in tests.

For Odis:

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Batting Average)

Matthew Hayden  <   Herschelle Gibbs(Batting Strike Rate)

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Runs in Innings)

Matthew Hayden  <   Herschelle Gibbs(Runs in Career)

Matthew Hayden  <   Herschelle Gibbs(Total Hundreds)

Its 2:3 means Herschelle Gibbs is best in odis.

For T20s:

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Batting Average)

Matthew Hayden  >   Herschelle Gibbs(Batting Strike Rate)

Matthew Hayden  <   Herschelle Gibbs(Runs in Innings)

Matthew Hayden  <   Herschelle Gibbs(Runs in Career)

Matthew Hayden  =   Herschelle Gibbs(Total Hundreds)

Its 2:2 means both are equally good in t20s.

Its 1:1 means both are equally good. Matthew Hayden played for Australia. Herschelle Gibbs played for South Africa. Both retired from International Cricket. Matthew Hayden was left handed opener batsman and Herschelle Gibbs was right handed opener batsman. They both were very explosive and attacking batsmen. They started attacking bowlers from the very first over. Bowlers were scared of bowling to them. Both played very good and impactful innings throughout their careers. Herschelle Gibbs is also known as the one of the best fielders in cricket history. Herschelle Gibbs admitted after sokme years of retirement that he was involved in match fixing. They both now involve in commentary.  Both have millions of fans. My favourite is Matthew Hayden because he destroyed any bowling attack in his time due to his attacking batting. Tell me your favourite with reasons. Tell me your favourite players to see their comparisons.